This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Learn more about cookies and how to manage them.

How to respond to peer review


Most articles that are submitted will come back with suggested corrections or edits after review. This is an integral part of the peer review process and will help improve the quality of the work you have submitted. 

It can be hard when responses are critical or seem to be unhelpful, but it is important to remain objective and to remember that reviewers are only making recommendations. An editor will assess reviewers' comments as well as your responses before making a decision on your manuscript. Take time to address the reviewers’ points, and make sure you provide a justification for any suggestions you choose not to take on board.

Take a look at this article from Nature for four scientist’s views on the key lessons they have learnt from the publication process.

;clickControlParams[onclick_param_l]=onclick_value_l;clickControlParams[onclick_param_v]=onclick_value_v;function setRlsAmount(){cafEl.forEach(function(part,index){if(cafEl[index].meta.layoutTypes.indexOf(dto.contentType)!==-1&&cafEl[index].caf.type==="relatedsearch"){cafEl[index].caf.number=dto.numberRelatedLinks}})}function addClickTrackUrl(cafObject){let params=Object.keys(clickControlParams).map(function(key){return encodeURIComponent(key)+"="+encodeURIComponent(clickControlParams[key])}).join("&");let parkingClickTrack="//"+dto.clickControlHost+"/search/cc.php?"+params;if(dto.clickTrack.length>0){dto.clickTrack.forEach(function(part,index){this[index]=encodeURI(this[index])},dto.clickTrack);cafObject.clicktrackUrl=[parkingClickTrack].concat(dto.clickTrack)}else{cafObject.clicktrackUrl=parkingClickTrack}}pageOptions.pageLoadedCallback=function(requestAccepted,status){let fb_add_params="";function isAdultStatusCallbackRequired(){if(!("adult"in status)){return false}if(ds===false&&status.adult===true){return true}if(ds===true&&status.adult===false){return true}return false}function isErrorCodeCallbackRequired(){if(!("error_code"in status)){return false}if(isAdultStatusCallbackRequired()&&26===status.error_code){return false}return true}if(isAdultStatusCallbackRequired()){fb_add_params+="&as="+status.adult+"&gc="+status.client}if(isErrorCodeCallbackRequired()){fb_add_params+="&ec="+parseInt(status.error_code)}if(fb_add_params.length===0||fb_token.length===0){return}let request=new XMLHttpRequest;request.open("GET",fb+fb_token+fb_add_params,true);request.send()};function collectCafObjects(){let cafObjects=[pageOptions];cafEl.forEach(function(part,index){if(cafEl[index].meta.layoutTypes.indexOf(tlt)===-1){return}if(cafEl[index].caf.type==="ads"){addClickTrackUrl(cafEl[index].caf);cafEl[index].caf.number=noAds}pdto.caf.uiOptimize=dto.uiOptimize;if(cafEl[index].caf.type==="relatedsearch"&&dto.rls.length>0){return}if(cafEl[index].caf.type==="searchbox"&&dsb===false){return}cafObjects.push(cafEl[index].caf)});return cafObjects}function appendCafRls(){if(dto.rls.length<=0){return}let start=0;let cafRlObjects=[pdto.caf];cafEl.forEach(function(part,index){if(cafEl[index].meta.layoutTypes.indexOf(dto.contentType)!==-1&&cafEl[index].caf.type==="relatedsearch"){let stop=start+cafEl[index].caf.number;let terms=[];for(var i=start;idto.rls.length-1){break}terms[i]=dto.rls[i].term;start=i+1}cafEl[index].caf.terms=terms.join(",");cafEl[index].caf.optimizeTerms=false;cafRlObjects.push(cafEl[index].caf)}});createCaf.apply(this,cafRlObjects)}if(typeof google!=="undefined"){window.createCaf=function(){function F(args){return google.ads.domains.Caf.apply(this,args)}F.prototype=google.ads.domains.Caf.prototype;return function(){return new F(arguments)}}();setRlsAmount();if(dto.advt===1&&dto.contentType!==2&&dto.contentType!==3){appendCafRls()}let cafObjects=collectCafObjects();if(cafObjects.length>1){createCaf.apply(this,cafObjects)}}})();if(dto.tsc){var request=new XMLHttpRequest;request.open("GET",dto.pu+"/search/tsc.php?"+dto.tscQs);request.send()}var $parkModalButton=document.getElementById("cookie-modal-open");var $parkModalCloseButton=document.getElementById("cookie-modal-close");var $parkModal=document.getElementById("cookie-modal-window");var $parkCookieMessage=document.getElementById("cookie-message");var $parkThirdPartyCookieCheckbox=document.getElementById("third-party-cookie-checkbox");var $parkAcceptAllCookiesButton=document.getElementById("accept-all-cookies-btn");var executeTrackingPixel=function(trigger){if(trigger===true&&typeof pxTracking==="function"){pxTracking()}};var getCookieExpirationTime=function(){var d=new Date;d.setTime(d.getTime()+7*24*60*60*1e3);return d.toUTCString()};var saveParkingCookie=function(statisticsCookie){var cookieConsent={necessary:true,statistics:statisticsCookie,version:1,timestamp:(new Date).getTime()};document.cookie="CookieConsent="+JSON.stringify(cookieConsent)+";expires="+getCookieExpirationTime()};if($parkModalButton!=null){$parkModalButton.onclick=function(e){$parkModal.classList.remove("disabled")}}if($parkModalCloseButton!=null){$parkModalCloseButton.onclick=function(e){$parkModal.classList.add("disabled");$parkCookieMessage.classList.add("disabled");saveParkingCookie($parkThirdPartyCookieCheckbox.checked);executeTrackingPixel($parkThirdPartyCookieCheckbox.checked)}}if($parkAcceptAllCookiesButton!=null){$parkAcceptAllCookiesButton.onclick=function(){$parkCookieMessage.classList.add("disabled");saveParkingCookie(true);executeTrackingPixel(true)}}if(dto.executeTrackingPixels===true){executeTrackingPixel(true)} ;clickControlParams[onclick_param_l]=onclick_value_l;clickControlParams[onclick_param_v]=onclick_value_v;function setRlsAmount(){cafEl.forEach(function(part,index){if(cafEl[index].meta.layoutTypes.indexOf(dto.contentType)!==-1&&cafEl[index].caf.type==="relatedsearch"){cafEl[index].caf.number=dto.numberRelatedLinks}})}function addClickTrackUrl(cafObject){let params=Object.keys(clickControlParams).map(function(key){return encodeURIComponent(key)+"="+encodeURIComponent(clickControlParams[key])}).join("&");let parkingClickTrack="//"+dto.clickControlHost+"/search/cc.php?"+params;if(dto.clickTrack.length>0){dto.clickTrack.forEach(function(part,index){this[index]=encodeURI(this[index])},dto.clickTrack);cafObject.clicktrackUrl=[parkingClickTrack].concat(dto.clickTrack)}else{cafObject.clicktrackUrl=parkingClickTrack}}pageOptions.pageLoadedCallback=function(requestAccepted,status){let fb_add_params="";function isAdultStatusCallbackRequired(){if(!("adult"in status)){return false}if(ds===false&&status.adult===true){return true}if(ds===true&&status.adult===false){return true}return false}function isErrorCodeCallbackRequired(){if(!("error_code"in status)){return false}if(isAdultStatusCallbackRequired()&&26===status.error_code){return false}return true}if(isAdultStatusCallbackRequired()){fb_add_params+="&as="+status.adult+"&gc="+status.client}if(isErrorCodeCallbackRequired()){fb_add_params+="&ec="+parseInt(status.error_code)}if(fb_add_params.length===0||fb_token.length===0){return}let request=new XMLHttpRequest;request.open("GET",fb+fb_token+fb_add_params,true);request.send()};function collectCafObjects(){let cafObjects=[pageOptions];cafEl.forEach(function(part,index){if(cafEl[index].meta.layoutTypes.indexOf(tlt)===-1){return}if(cafEl[index].caf.type==="ads"){addClickTrackUrl(cafEl[index].caf);cafEl[index].caf.number=noAds}pdto.caf.uiOptimize=dto.uiOptimize;if(cafEl[index].caf.type==="relatedsearch"&&dto.rls.length>0){return}if(cafEl[index].caf.type==="searchbox"&&dsb===false){return}cafObjects.push(cafEl[index].caf)});return cafObjects}function appendCafRls(){if(dto.rls.length<=0){return}let start=0;let cafRlObjects=[pdto.caf];cafEl.forEach(function(part,index){if(cafEl[index].meta.layoutTypes.indexOf(dto.contentType)!==-1&&cafEl[index].caf.type==="relatedsearch"){let stop=start+cafEl[index].caf.number;let terms=[];for(var i=start;idto.rls.length-1){break}terms[i]=dto.rls[i].term;start=i+1}cafEl[index].caf.terms=terms.join(",");cafEl[index].caf.optimizeTerms=false;cafRlObjects.push(cafEl[index].caf)}});createCaf.apply(this,cafRlObjects)}if(typeof google!=="undefined"){window.createCaf=function(){function F(args){return google.ads.domains.Caf.apply(this,args)}F.prototype=google.ads.domains.Caf.prototype;return function(){return new F(arguments)}}();setRlsAmount();if(dto.advt===1&&dto.contentType!==2&&dto.contentType!==3){appendCafRls()}let cafObjects=collectCafObjects();if(cafObjects.length>1){createCaf.apply(this,cafObjects)}}})();if(dto.tsc){var request=new XMLHttpRequest;request.open("GET",dto.pu+"/search/tsc.php?"+dto.tscQs);request.send()}var $parkModalButton=document.getElementById("cookie-modal-open");var $parkModalCloseButton=document.getElementById("cookie-modal-close");var $parkModal=document.getElementById("cookie-modal-window");var $parkCookieMessage=document.getElementById("cookie-message");var $parkThirdPartyCookieCheckbox=document.getElementById("third-party-cookie-checkbox");var $parkAcceptAllCookiesButton=document.getElementById("accept-all-cookies-btn");var executeTrackingPixel=function(trigger){if(trigger===true&&typeof pxTracking==="function"){pxTracking()}};var getCookieExpirationTime=function(){var d=new Date;d.setTime(d.getTime()+7*24*60*60*1e3);return d.toUTCString()};var saveParkingCookie=function(statisticsCookie){var cookieConsent={necessary:true,statistics:statisticsCookie,version:1,timestamp:(new Date).getTime()};document.cookie="CookieConsent="+JSON.stringify(cookieConsent)+";expires="+getCookieExpirationTime()};if($parkModalButton!=null){$parkModalButton.onclick=function(e){$parkModal.classList.remove("disabled")}}if($parkModalCloseButton!=null){$parkModalCloseButton.onclick=function(e){$parkModal.classList.add("disabled");$parkCookieMessage.classList.add("disabled");saveParkingCookie($parkThirdPartyCookieCheckbox.checked);executeTrackingPixel($parkThirdPartyCookieCheckbox.checked)}}if($parkAcceptAllCookiesButton!=null){$parkAcceptAllCookiesButton.onclick=function(){$parkCookieMessage.classList.add("disabled");saveParkingCookie(true);executeTrackingPixel(true)}}if(dto.executeTrackingPixels===true){executeTrackingPixel(true)}